The role of the Physician Assistant (PA) in modern medicine has been expanding for decades, yet confusion persists about the precise nature of their responsibilities and how they are compared to medical doctors (MDs) and doctors of osteopathic medicine (DOs). Patients, legislators, and even some healthcare professionals frequently ask: Is a physician assistant a doctor?

This question isn’t merely academic—it has real-world implications for healthcare policy, patient safety, medical liability, and the efficiency of healthcare delivery. As someone deeply immersed in the healthcare profession, I have seen firsthand how the differences (and sometimes overlaps) between PAs and physicians affect clinical workflows, patient perceptions, and even professional dynamics within the healthcare team.

In this article, I will comprehensively examine the key distinctions between PAs and physicians, covering their training, scope of practice, legal status, prescriptive authority, autonomy, and professional identity. By the end, it should be crystal clear why PAs and physicians are not the same, why the confusion exists, and what the future holds for the PA profession in relation to the traditional role of the physician.

The physician assistant profession was created as a direct response to a growing shortage of physicians in the United States in the 1960s. During this period, the U.S. healthcare system was grappling with a severe lack of primary care doctors, particularly in rural and underserved areas.

A significant portion of this crisis was due to the increasing complexity of medical education—physicians had to undergo years of extensive schooling and residency, delaying their entry into independent practice. However, during the same period, military medics and corpsmen returning from Vietnam had acquired advanced medical training and hands-on experience but had no equivalent civilian role where they could apply their skills.

In 1965, Dr. Eugene Stead at Duke University recognized this gap and proposed a new type of medical professional—one who could be trained faster than a physician but who could still perform highly skilled medical tasks under the supervision of a doctor. This led to the creation of the first physician assistant program, modeled after the accelerated training programs used for physicians during World War II.

Initially, PAs were trained primarily for primary care settings, functioning as physician extenders rather than independent practitioners. However, as the demand for medical providers grew, PAs began to enter more specialized fields such as emergency medicine, surgery, cardiology, and oncology.

In the 1970s, formal accreditation standards were introduced to ensure consistency in PA education, leading to the establishment of the Accreditation Review Commission on Education for the Physician Assistant (ARC-PA). Over time, PAs gained expanded prescriptive rights, broader procedural capabilities, and more autonomy in patient management, particularly in team-based healthcare models.

Today, PAs practice across every medical specialty, often taking on roles that were previously exclusive to physicians. Yet, despite these advances, their education, legal standing, and scope of practice remain distinct from that of a physician.

One of the most defining differences between physician assistants and physicians is their educational trajectory. While both PAs and MDs/DOs must meet rigorous entry requirements, the scope, depth, and duration of their training differ significantly.

• PA Programs
  ○ Require a bachelor’s degree, typically in a health-related field.
  ○ Competitive admission process, with most programs requiring thousands of hours of direct patient care experience before entry (e.g., EMTs, nurses, paramedics).
  ○ Some PA programs accept the GRE or, less commonly, the MCAT for admission.
• Medical Schools (MD/DO)
  ○ Require a bachelor’s degree with a heavy focus on sciences, such as biochemistry, organic chemistry, and physics.
  ○ Significantly more competitive than PA school, with most applicants required to take the Medical College Admission Test (MCAT).
  ○ Research experience, clinical shadowing, and academic excellence are critical for acceptance.

The most striking difference between PA and physician training is depth and duration.

PA Training (2-3 Years, Master’s Level)

• PA programs are highly condensed, covering a wide breadth of medical knowledge but with fewer total clinical hours.
• A typical PA program consists of one year of didactic coursework, followed by one year of clinical rotations.
• PA clinical training includes about 2,000 hours of patient care experience.
• PA education is focused on practical, application-based training, allowing PAs to enter the workforce more quickly.

Medical School and Residency (7-12 Years Total)

• Medical school alone takes four years, with the first two dedicated to basic sciences and the last two to clinical rotations.
• Physicians must complete a minimum of 3 years of residency training, with some specialties requiring up to 7 years or more.
• By the time a physician completes their residency, they have accumulated 12,000 to 16,000 hours of supervised clinical training—far more than a PA.

The core distinction between a PA and a physician is not just time but the level of depth and expertise acquired. PAs are trained as generalists and work under physician supervision, while physicians undergo specialized, exhaustive training that allows them to manage complex, high-risk, and critically ill patients independently.

Physicians are fully autonomous medical professionals who make independent clinical decisions and assume full legal responsibility for patient care.

PAs, on the other hand, function under a delegated practice model, meaning they work in collaboration with physicians rather than as independent practitioners.

Supervision Models and Variability

• Some states grant full practice authority to experienced PAs, allowing them to function without direct supervision.
• However, in most regions, PAs must practice under a written agreement with a supervising physician.
• Supervisory requirements vary depending on state laws, hospital policies, and specialty-specific regulations.

Prescriptive Authority and Procedural Limits

• PAs can prescribe medications, but some states place restrictions on controlled substances (e.g., opioids, benzodiazepines).
• PAs can perform procedures (e.g., suturing, lumbar punctures, joint injections), but complex surgeries remain within the domain of physicians.
• PAs can assist in surgery, but they do not lead surgical procedures independently.

One of the primary reasons for the confusion between physician assistants (PAs) and doctors is the significant overlap in their daily responsibilities, particularly in clinical settings where PAs often perform many of the same tasks as physicians. However, while there are shared duties, the key difference lies in the level of responsibility, decision-making authority, and ultimate clinical oversight.

In primary care, PAs frequently serve as the first point of contact for patients, handling routine check-ups, diagnosing and treating common conditions, and managing chronic diseases like diabetes, hypertension, and asthma. Many primary care physicians work with PAs to extend their reach, allowing them to see more patients per day while maintaining quality care.

A PA in a primary care setting can:

• Conduct comprehensive physical exams.
• Diagnose and treat common illnesses and chronic conditions.
• Order and interpret laboratory tests, imaging studies, and EKGs.
• Provide preventive care, including vaccinations and lifestyle counseling.
• Prescribe medications within the limits set by state law.

However, PAs in primary care typically refer complex cases to physicians when patients require a higher level of medical expertise, such as managing multi-system diseases, interpreting ambiguous diagnostic results, or coordinating specialized treatment plans.

In emergency departments, PAs play a critical role in triaging and managing acutely ill or injured patients, often working side by side with physicians. In many cases, PAs handle lower-acuity cases independently, freeing up physicians to manage more severe or life-threatening emergencies.

A PA in emergency medicine may:

• Perform initial patient assessments and order necessary tests.
• Administer treatments for common emergency conditions (e.g., minor fractures, lacerations, infections).
• Perform procedures such as wound closures, joint reductions, lumbar punctures, and central line placements.
• Assist in resuscitation and trauma management, but final decisions on critical cases rest with the physician.

Despite their broad scope in emergency medicine, PAs typically do not handle major trauma, advanced cardiac cases, or critically unstable patients without physician consultation. The final responsibility for high-risk medical decisions always rests with the attending physician.

PAs are increasingly involved in surgical care, often serving as first assistants during procedures. They play an integral role in preoperative, intraoperative, and postoperative care, handling many responsibilities that allow surgeons to focus on the most technically demanding aspects of an operation.

A PA in a surgical setting can:

• Conduct preoperative evaluations and obtain informed consent.
• Assist in the operating room by retracting tissues, suturing, and closing incisions.
• Perform postoperative wound care and manage post-surgical complications.
• Oversee patient recovery, pain management, and discharge planning.

However, while PAs are trained to assist in surgery, they do not perform surgery independently. The role of lead surgeon remains exclusive to physicians who have completed years of specialized surgical residency and fellowships.

In hospital settings, particularly critical care units (ICUs), cardiology wards, and internal medicine departments, PAs function as integral members of the inpatient care team. Many hospitals utilize PAs in rounding teams, allowing them to handle routine inpatient management while physicians focus on complex cases, interventional procedures, and advanced diagnostics.

A PA in a hospital setting may:

• Monitor and manage postoperative and acutely ill patients.
• Adjust medication regimens under the guidance of hospital protocols.
• Conduct procedures such as thoracentesis, paracentesis, and intubations (with training).
• Coordinate patient discharges and follow-up plans.

However, PAs in critical care settings typically operate within structured care protocols and consult attending physicians when patient conditions deteriorate or when high-risk interventions are required.

While both PAs and physicians must be licensed to practice, the requirements and governing bodies that oversee their certifications are distinct.

• Physician Assistant Licensing (PA-C)
  ○ All PAs must pass the Physician Assistant National Certifying Exam (PANCE), administered by the National Commission on Certification of Physician Assistants (NCCPA).
  ○ To maintain certification, PAs must complete 100 hours of continuing medical education (CME) every two years and pass a recertification exam every 10 years.
• Physician Licensing (MD/DO)
  ○ Physicians must pass the United States Medical Licensing Examination (USMLE) for MDs or the Comprehensive Osteopathic Medical Licensing Examination (COMLEX) for DOs.
  ○ Unlike PAs, physicians must complete residency training and obtain board certification in their specialty.

One of the most debated topics in PA practice is the degree of autonomy and supervision required. The laws governing PA practice vary widely by state and country, with some states allowing PAs to practice independently while others require strict physician oversight.

• Full Practice Authority (Few States)
  ○ In certain states, experienced PAs can practice independently and prescribe controlled substances without physician collaboration.
  ○ These states often require additional experience and credentialing before granting full practice rights.
• Collaborative Agreements (Majority of U.S. States)
  ○ Most states mandate that PAs work under written agreements with a supervising physician, outlining their scope of practice.
  ○ PAs can see patients and prescribe medications but must consult with a physician for complex cases.
• Strict Supervision (Certain Jurisdictions)
  ○ Some states and hospital systems require direct physician supervision, meaning a physician must be physically present or immediately available.

From a medical liability perspective, PAs are held to a different standard than physicians.

• PAs are legally tied to their supervising physicians, meaning that if a PA makes a critical medical error, the physician may share legal responsibility.
• Physicians, as independent practitioners, bear full legal responsibility for all their clinical decisions.
• Malpractice insurance costs for PAs are significantly lower than for physicians, reflecting their reduced legal liability and supervised role.

A particularly controversial issue in modern healthcare is whether PAs—particularly those who obtain a Doctorate of Medical Science (DMSc)—should be allowed to use the title “doctor.”

• Patient Confusion
  ○ Studies show that patients often struggle to differentiate between various healthcare providers. Using the title “doctor” could mislead patients into thinking a PA is a physician.
• AMA and Medical Associations’ Stance
  ○ The American Medical Association (AMA) strongly opposes non-physicians using the title “doctor” in clinical settings, citing concerns over role misrepresentation and patient safety.

• Academic Merit
  ○ Some PAs earn a Doctorate of Medical Science (DMSc), a relatively new credential aimed at advancing leadership, research, and healthcare policy expertise.
  ○ Proponents argue that, in academic settings, PAs with a doctorate should have the right to use their earned title just as pharmacists and physical therapists do.
• Clarification with Context
  ○ Some believe PAs could use the title “Doctor” in non-clinical settings or with a clear distinction (e.g., “Dr. Smith, PA-C”).

While PAs provide high-quality, patient-centered care, their role is fundamentally different from that of a physician. Understanding these distinctions is not about diminishing the value of PAs but about ensuring clear role definitions for patient safety, healthcare efficiency, and professional clarity.

As the healthcare system continues to evolve, the collaboration between PAs and physicians will remain essential. However, as autonomy laws change and educational programs expand, ongoing discussions will shape the future of PAs in medicine.

One thing remains certain: the physician assistant profession will continue to play a crucial role in bridging the gap between patients and physicians, enhancing healthcare accessibility, and improving patient outcomes.

As we’ve explored in this article, physician assistants play a vital role in modern healthcare, but their ability to practice is often shaped by state-mandated collaboration requirements. While some states are moving toward increased PA autonomy, many still require a formal relationship with a collaborating physician to ensure compliance with state laws and maintain high standards of patient care.

At Collaborating Docs, we understand the challenges that PAs face when trying to secure the right physician collaboration—one that not only meets state regulatory requirements but also provides meaningful professional support. Founded by Dr. Annie DePasquale in 2020, we were the first-to-market solution designed specifically to help PAs and NPs connect with experienced, state-compliant collaborating physicians.

With a network of over 2,000 qualified physicians, we have facilitated more than 5,000 successful collaborations, helping PAs navigate complex legal requirements while ensuring they can practice with confidence. Unlike generic matching services that treat collaborations as just a signature requirement, we prioritize meaningful, high-quality partnerships—because having the right physician collaborator can enhance your clinical practice, professional growth, and long-term success.

✔ Guaranteed Compliance – We ensure that every collaboration meets state-mandated legal and regulatory standards, keeping your license protected.
✔ Fast, Reliable Matching – Get paired with the right collaborating physician in 14 days or less, with 97% of matches completed in under 7 days.
✔ A Network That Works for You – Our extensive network includes physicians across all specialties, ensuring the perfect fit for your specific practice needs.
✔ Beyond the Minimums – We don’t just connect you with a name on paper. Our physicians are selected to provide valuable clinical insight, guidance, and mentorship when needed.
✔ Proven Expertise & Experience – As the premier leader in PA and NP collaborations, we’ve set the gold standard in compliance, reliability, and professionalism.

If you’re a PA or NP looking for a hassle-free, legally compliant, and high-quality physician collaboration, let Collaborating Docs be your trusted partner.

Get started today! Visit our website to secure your collaborating physician quickly, correctly, and with confidence.